When I read Traveller a while back I wrote a bit about the OSR, people going back to playing old school games, or making new games with the same feel as the old games, mostly D&D.
My experiences with the old school of D&D are pretty limited. I played red box D&D once, my character was an elf, who died of poisoning after less than an hour of play. We never came back to D&D after that, but we played some 2ed Ad&d, and when I was at the university I played a bit of 3ed D&D. But lately I have had an interest in trying old school D&D again, just to see what I have been missing.
When the first snow fell James Edward Raggi IV had a snow-sale of his game Lamentations of the Flame Princess – Weird Fantasy Role-Playing, and since I had heard good things about it, and it has a very nice cover I gave in and Paypaled the money to Finland. The game came a week later and has been sitting on my shelf since…
The game comes in a box. It has been a while since I last bought a boxed game, boxes are expensive to make, and makes for more expensive games. It is not the usual two part box, but an elaborately cut and folded single piece one. I doubt that it is as durable as the old style of game boxes, but I suppose it is a while lot cheaper.
Inside the box there are dice, character sheets, a pencil, hex and graph paper, a Tutorial book, a Rules book, a Referee book, a Magic book and two adventure books. Lots of stuff, everything in A5 format.
The box cover art by Cynthia Sheppard is great, and it is also used on the Rules book and the Referee book. The rest of the illustrations are by a whole horde of artists, and are of average quality at the best.
The text is in a two column layout, and it is pretty small. It is nice to read and James writes in a friendly tone, but it takes a while to read the whole thing,
There is not much in the way of setting in the game. The two adventures have setting, but they are sort of separate from the game itself. It supports the generic fantasy medieval stuff with elves and wizards. The PCs are supposed to be given some sort of reason for heading down into dungeons to bash monsters, solve riddles, survive traps, loot riches and gain experience.
The traditional six stats 3-18, and a class (Cleric, Fighter, Elf etc) make the basis for a character. Buy some equipment and possibly hire some henchmen and the PCs are ready to go questing. Levels up to 20 are covered.
Combat is similarly simple on the surface, roll a d20 higher than the opponent’s armor to hit, then roll the weapon’s damage and subtract that from his hit points. But there are special rules for a number of situations that give the system some tactical depth.
There are subsystems for ship’s combat, owning slaves and property, and other things useful when the characters have gained enough money. One good way to make money seems to be to buy cartloads of spears at 1GP each, have a hireling tear off the blades, and then selling them as staves at 5GP each.
The form is traditional, one GM (called referee) and a set of players. Dungeons are explored and mapped on a room to room basis, monsters bashed along the way.
But it is not assumed that the reader is familiar with this play style, the whole first book, Tutorial, is dedicated to explaining it. First through two simple solo adventures, the latter involving loads of jumping back and forth between numbered paragraphs in a chose your own adventure game. There is also a transcription of a game session, showing the thin veil between the story level and play level of the game, including a tongue-in-cheek discussion between the players regarding if whether the things they say are heard by NPCs .
The Referee book contains very little in the way of rules, instead it very clearly explains how to prepare and run a game. It is very detailed in it’s instructions, and gives lots of advice on how to run a fun game.
The setting is weak, but frankly, how much do you need to go dungeon bashing?
The rules are good, at least as far as I can tell, they are intended to replicate the feeling of the old D&D style games, and I think they do.
The form is excellent. The tutorial and referee books together would be a good introduction into gaming for beginners, at least if they manage to stay interested in spite of the rather bland graphical presentation of the material (the text itself is rather nice). And experienced gamers unfamiliar with the old school style of gaming can learn it here.
Will I play it?
No, I don’t think so. I have left dungeon bashing behind me, the style of play where you are actually expected to map your surroundings and solve riddles doesn’t appeal to me anymore.
Maybe I could run it as a gag game at a convention, but then I think I would go back to the red box D&D, just so that the neophytes could join online discussions and talk about what games were like thirty years ago.
Not a bad game, but not a game for me.
www.lotfp.com/RPG/products/lotfp-weird-fantasy-role-playing – Official site for the game.