Back in January I read A Taste for Murder. It seemed like a nice game at the time, even if I complained about the lack of character sheets for downlaod, and feared that I would need to translate stuff before playing.
We drew our own character sheets and translated the circles on the spot. And now that I have played four games I thought I’d return to the game with a Playing post to make a report on how the game works in actual play.
When having four players it fits comfortably into a four hour slot. At five and six it might feel a bit rushed, at least at when going into some detail in the side scenes. That said I think the sweet spot is five players. With six there’s a little too much down time, and at four play feels a bit constricted in act two when one player moves on to playing Chapel.
It would have been nice if all the tables (weather, activities and rooms) were on the same spread, as it is every group scene is preceded by frantic page turning, but that is a minor problem.
I have seen the game go some pretty dark places, quite possibly due to the preferences of the groups I have played with. And while we’ve never seen darkness at Montsegur 1244 levels, I still think I’ll make a mention of it while pitching the game at cons, so the players can make an informed choice of whether to pick another game instead.
We have drifted the game a bit. In the denoument scene at the end of the game, it usually turns into a shouting match between the prime suspects, rather them taking turns making their respective defenses. It has worked out well enough, and I see no reason to enforce the sequential way suggested in the rules.
In conclusion it is a nice game that captures the murder drama genre very well, even if it never becomes much of a mystery since no one is really looking for clues and there’s no real investigation in the game.